The Shot List
The Weekly Shot List printed on a card, leaning on marble beside a ceramic vase
Chanel, fine'ry, Estée Lauder, Dior Beauty, and Clarins: Christmas Campaigns, One Fake Paris
FragranceCosmetics

Chanel, fine'ry, Estée Lauder, Dior Beauty, and Clarins: Christmas Campaigns, One Fake Paris

Five Christmas campaigns, four shot for real and one perfect Paris image that was never shot at all.

Winter is the thread in this issue. Five Christmas campaigns, four shot for real and one perfect Paris scene that was never shot at all. Four real shoots and one generated image, and the difference is the story.

Chanel Les Exclusifs de Chanel Discovery Set: A Winter World Built Small

Chanel (@chanel.beauty) builds a whole winter world focused on the gift set of Perfume minis. They last year christmas campaign was my favorite so I was really looking forward to what they will do this year.

This year it is the opposite - all white and bright, but still restrained. The snow is what I keep looking at. It sits fine and uneven, the way real snow lands, and small snow is hard to fake well. Soft, bright light keeps the mood calm while acrylic surface below stretches the set and gives the holiday sleeve room to repeat in reflection.

My favorite thing about this photo is how they keep everything intentional - the mountains on the background are fully covered in snow, but on the actual scene is it quite minimal, to support the story. Because of that you can clearly see the products with the logo reflected on the acrylic, which again reinforces the brand.

Wherever you look you see their branding and that's the power of a perfect commercial photo.

https://www.chanel.com/us/fragrance/p/101269/les-exclusifs-de-chanel-discovery-set-5-eaux-de-parfum/

fine'ry Best of Vanilla Gift Set: Snow, Skis, One Smart Reflection

fine'ry (@fineryfragrance) created a skiing set for their products, shot with the imitation of sunset. The set is three of its best-selling vanilla minis: Athena, Sweet on the Outside and Fireside Vanille. Two images have two separate jobs.

First, the products in their winter holiday packaging, shot from above. Crossed skis cut diagonals through the frame and land the eye on the box. White on white is risky, yet the snow holds texture and shadow, and nothing goes flat. Then the bottles come out. Against a goggle lens, the mountain reflecting behind them, a lineup becomes the read: labels clean, caps catching the sun. Vanilla reads warm, snow reads cold, and they give the gift a winter world.

https://www.target.com/p/fine-39-ry-womens-39-mini-vanilla-body-mist-gift-set-trio-sweet-on-the-outside-athena-38-fireside-2-5-fl-oz-3ct/-/A-95254445

Estée Lauder Holiday Essentials: Warm Light Holds The Range Together

First time for Estée Lauder (@esteelauder) here, and the pick is a group shot with a clear job: show the range in one frame for a holiday stay.

Warm side light carries that job. Glass, amber, frosted finishes and polished gold all read at once because the light stays warm and directional across them, instead of going flat and even. Shadows from the wall panels give the upper half room, so the dense lower half can stay rich without tipping into clutter.

That balance is the brand for me. Old house, modern control. Red runs through the frame as a holiday accent, small and confident, and the whole set reads as a gift before any single product asks for attention.

https://www.esteelauder.com/holiday-beauty-gift-guide

Dior Beauty J'adore Diamond River: Hard Light, Pure Celebration

Dior Beauty (@diorbeauty) is back one issue after the last L'Or de J'adore I reviewed, the numbered edition by Madina Visconti. This one is J'adore Diamond River, five pieces worldwide, composed by Francis Kurkdjian, with a 2.2 carat diamond sitting inside the glass stopper.

The light is not just a couple of diffusers. It also has lots of hard light sources, which could be metallic reflectors or mirrors, and that gives the bottle a really luxurious feel. Instead of flattening everything, it creates different shapes and points of interest. It makes the bottle feel celebratory too, like a Christmas tree, or Belle in her dress - all attention goes to her.

The full bottle shot sets the silhouette. The close-up proves the craft, facet by facet.

https://www.dior.com/en_ca/beauty/fragrance/exceptional-fragrance/exceptional-pieces

Clarins Double Serum Foundation: A Shoot That Never Happened In Paris

Clarins (@clarinsofficial) posted this as a real hero shot, and it is AI generated.

I want to call it AI slop, as they didn't even try to make it realistic.

Clarins sells a foundation with a serum phase, 37 shades, real product that real skin has to wear. A generated winter postcard sells the idea without anyone picking up a camera. For a house this big, that choice is the story.

Winter campaign shot done carelessly in Chat GPT for a product that sells at $74 is really disappointing.

Some of their AI generated content is “fine”, but these look really bad for a brand their size, whose products I genuinely love.

https://www.clarinsusa.com/en/double-serum-foundation/CS01581782.html

Elina is a Ukrainian-Canadian commercial photographer based in Vancouver, British Columbia.

Get in touch

Instagram: @elina.kustlyvy

X (Twitter): @elinakustlyvy

Photographers: If I've featured your work and you'd like a credit or to be tagged, DM me your details. I'm happy to update and showcase your name.

Read our editorial disclaimer and fair use policy

Get the next issue

New reviews of beauty and fragrance photography, in your inbox every week.